-
Amanda Smith, 47, spent three nights in jail and faces up to six years in prison. A scammer opened a Cash App account with her Social Security number.
-
The account’s phone number, address, device, and mobile carrier do not match Smith.
-
Cash App refused to share the account details because she could not prove it was hers. She saw the data only through her court case.
An Arkansas fraud case has landed on a Pennsylvania woman who says she has never used Cash App. Police say an account in Amanda Smith’s name collected $1,000 from a scam victim. 404 Media reported her story on Oct. 21. Six months in, she is still fighting the charges. Her next hearing is in November.
Amanda’s Arrest and Bail
One afternoon in April, Smith opened her door and found sheriff’s deputies. They held a warrant for computer fraud. The alleged crime happened in Arkansas, more than 1,000 miles from her home in upstate Pennsylvania. She says she has never been to that state.
Deputies took her to the local jail in handcuffs. She stayed three nights. For days, she did not know why she was there.
Later, she appeared at an extradition hearing in chains. Bail was set at $50,000. Smith says officers told her not to pay, since they planned to send her to Arkansas anyway. Instead, they released her. The next week, she and her husband, Josh, drove to Arkansas for a court date. After a second bail of $20,000, she went home.
How Police Found Her
The case began Feb. 4, when Arkansas police took a fraud report. The victim had found items for sale on Facebook Marketplace. The seller told him to pay through his wife’s Cash App account, so he sent $1,000. Investigators later learned that someone had hacked the seller’s Facebook account. No real sale existed.
The Cash App account carried Smith’s name and the username $Smithy5687. Someone opened it at the end of January, just before the scam. Investigators sent a search warrant to Block, the company behind Cash App. The records it returned included Smith’s Social Security number and date of birth.
Next, Detective Poole checked her driver’s license and ran her details through Accurint, a tool police use to search records. Smith now faces charges of computer fraud, unlawful use of a communication device, and theft of property.
Some Details About the Cash App Account Don’t Add Up
404 Media reviewed the account data from her case. Much of it points away from Smith. The Philadelphia address on the account is not hers or Josh’s.
The phone number is not her current one. Smith says she may have used it in the early 2000s. Meanwhile, the account used an iPhone running iOS 16.1.1, a 2022 version. Smith owns an iPhone 13 mini with iOS 26.5.2, based on a screenshot she shared.
The internet addresses tied to the account came from Verizon’s wireless network. Smith uses AT&T and says she has never had Verizon. She also says she never used that username.
404 Media also found a Venmo account that used the same phone number under a different name. Someone made it about a week before the Cash App account. Hours after the $1,000 arrived, the account sent small amounts to other accounts. Some appear to belong to scammers.
No Response From Cash App
Smith first asked Cash App for details herself. The company told her it could share nothing because she could not prove she owned the account. “They’re trying to turn it into my problem,” she told 404 Media. In her view, she must now prove her own innocence.
Her private investigator, Max Ponte, questions whether police showed she controlled the account. Her lawyer, Jason Horton, wants the case dismissed before trial. He says police should have investigated more before arresting her.
Cash App did not answer repeated requests for comment. The prosecutor, Jeffrey Sams, did not respond either. Authorities offered Smith a plea deal: a $1,000 fine, $1,000 in restitution, court fees, and three years of probation. She refuses. She says she is innocent.
Why Stolen Data is a Goldmine for Criminals
Block says users must provide a full name, date of birth, address, and Social Security number. Cash App’s terms also describe a check against Social Security records. That check shows the data is real. It cannot show who typed it in.
Smith suspects a data breach, such as the National Public Data leak. Security firms said that leak exposed about 272 million Social Security numbers. Smith has not confirmed that her data was part of it.
Separately, French prosecutors have opened an investigation into alleged exploitation and trafficking involving the Al-Fayed family, highlighting another ongoing criminal investigation in Europe.
Actionable Steps for Identity Theft Victims
The Federal Trade Commission lists three steps for identity theft victims. First, call the companies where the fraud took place and let them know what happened, then change your login details.
Second, place a free credit freeze and a free one-year fraud alert. Also, check your credit reports for free at AnnualCreditReport.com. Third, report the theft at IdentityTheft.gov to get a recovery plan.
No court has ruled that Smith committed the fraud, and no conviction has been reported. For now, she is waiting to see what November brings.